Finding the Best Cash Back Credit Card for Your Needs

There are three types of cash back credit cards, any one of which could be best for you:

• Flat-rate.
• Tiered.
• Rotating bonus.

Each has different pros and cons. 

Flat-rate. These cash back credit cards offer the same percentage back on every purchase made with that card, typically 1 to 1.5%. So, if you spend $1,000 every month you’d get $10-15 back – usually as a statement credit.²

Pros of flat-rate cash back cards:

• Easy to understand – the reward is always the same.
• Usually no annual fee.
• Usually no limit to the amount of cash back you can earn.
• Could be your best cash back credit card choice if your buying spreads by-and-large equally across many different spending categories.

Cons of flat-rate cash back cards:

• Low overall cash back rewards of 2% or less compared to rotating bonus cards, which can offer up to 5% back.
• You can miss out on bigger rewards if spend concentrates in one or two categories – say, groceries and gas.

Tiered. Tiered cash back credit cards offer a higher cash back percentage in certain spending categories like groceries or gas, and a lower rate on all other purchases. For example, you might get 3% back on groceries, 2% on gas, and 1% on all other purchases.³

Pros of tiered cash back cards:

• Extra cash back rewards in specific categories.
• Better rewards if you spend a lot on specific categories like travel, groceries, gas, etc., or if you’re willing to concentrate spending in one area.

Cons of tiered cash back cards:

• More likely to have annual fees..
• Rewards can be small outside of bonus categories.
• There might be a limit on cash back in high-tier categories.

Rotating bonus. The spending categories on which you can earn higher cash back percentages change periodically with rotating bonus cards. For example, you might get 5% back on gas from April to June, and 5% back on dining from July to September. Other purchases usually get a 1% return. The higher reward category usually changes every three months or so, but you won’t receive the higher cash back percentage automatically – you typically need to opt in for bonus rewards in advance. Most card issuers release a calendar of all bonus categories for each year, so you know what to expect and when to opt-in.

Pros of rotating bonus cash back cards:

• Usually no annual fee.
• Best cash back rewards in specific rotating categories.
• Categories reflect everyday purchases, like gas, groceries, dining, and home improvement.

Cons of rotating bonus cash back cards:

• Extra rewards from bonus categories not automatic – you must activate them in advance.
• Cash back in bonus categories may be limited – you might receive 5% for the first $1,500 spent and 1% thereafter.

Regardless of the type of rewards credit card you choose – points, miles, or cash back – you’ll be able to earn or save a little money by spending money. But there’s a difference between how cash back credit cards work versus points and miles reward systems.⁴

Rewards points and miles cards: You can usually only use points to buy things offered by the card issuer. Depending on the card, this can range anywhere from plane tickets to gift cards to gasoline. They’re also harder to understand, since the value of points and miles rarely equals a dollar – and the value can change depending on where you redeem your points.⁵

Cash back cards: A cash back card allows you to earn a percentage of each qualifying purchase in the form of dollars or points. Depending on the card, you may earn cash back at a flat rate or earn different percentages based on the type of purchase category, like groceries, dining out, or gas. You’ll typically get cash back in a lump sum at the end of each billing cycle or statement period. Then, you can choose how to redeem it. The best cash back credit cards offer multiple ways to redeem rewards, such as charitable donations, gift cards, and statement credits. Many Americans prefer cash back cards to points cards because they’re easy to understand. After all, cash back rewards have a clear exchange rate with dollars and cents – and a dollar’s a dollar! 

None of which should suggest that points and miles cards aren’t worth it, depending on your lifestyle. They can offer lucrative rewards if you’re a big traveler. Understanding and redeeming your points just requires a bit more effort – and math skills.