The Value of a Year end Marketing Review

Every year my team and I review our marketing plans and identify ways we can make the next year better. We call it our annual year-end marketing review.

A marketing review allows you to analyze your performance, acknowledge your accomplishments, learn from your misses, and plot a course for the year ahead. They’re like annual check-ups, providing an overview of your business’s health, helping to ensure your marketing strategies remain effective and you’re keeping up with industry trends and customer demands. They also provide insights that can lead to key business decisions and stronger customer connections for years to come.

Last year, during our annual review at my marketing studio, Tote + Pears, we documented critical changes we’d suspected – that government policies, the political climate, and our clients' needs had shifted. As a result, we decided it was the right time to make some adjustments to our branding and marketing strategy to stay competitive.

It’s been a part of our strategic planning process for over a decade, and every year we come out of the experience better than before. Let's delve into what a year-end marketing review is and how our most recent reviews are propelling us forward.

Step 1: Conduct the Review

At Tote + Pears, our year-end marketing review kicks off by carefully assessing all the marketing activities undertaken throughout the year, complete with a deep dive into both the wins and misses. We evaluate our key performance indicators (KPIs) like overall website traffic, organic search rankings, social media engagement, email click-through rates, lead-generation metrics, and conversion rates. Then we examine our work from all angles – from designs to messaging to copy – with the goal of understanding what resonated with our audience and what got lost. This analysis gives us insights into how we can develop more effective strategies in the future.

Our review process can take anywhere from 4-12 weeks, depending on whether the initial review reveals a need for additional research and analysis. Last year, we noticed a significant shift in the market that required extra time. We conducted a market analysis and met with advisors and other stakeholders like employees, contractors, and partners. This process gave us all the data points needed to develop a strategy to adjust.

Step 2: Learn and Adjust

What I love about our year-end reviews is how much better they make us. Looking back allows us to spotlight areas where we’re excelling and the places where we can improve. These exercises give me the data I need to make decisions, including some that can be critical for our business – driving new strategies and pivots in our agency.

For example, during a previous year's year-end marketing review, we discovered our podcast was one of our most successful pieces of content. Clients loved hearing our perspective on certain topics, potential employees found the content helpful in their day-to-day jobs, and it opened up doors for collaboration with new partners. Harnessing these insights, we adjusted our strategy, focusing more on quality content and targeted engagement. This resulted in higher-end and more valuable talent, partners, and customers.

"What I love about our year-end reviews is how much better they make us. Looking back allows us to spotlight areas where we’re excelling and the places where we can improve."

Step 3: Capitalize on Success

The year-end review also cites our successes, which gives us an opportunity to make the most of those wins. For example, we recently uncovered that some of our market research had resulted in double-digit returns for a number of our clients. We used this opportunity to ask our clients to tell others about us and refer work our way.

Plus, we saw these wins as opportunities to give our team members a boost. We reminded our team how wonderful they are by providing rewards bonuses and gifts like meal services and event tickets. Taking a moment to reflect and reward them helped us build our team’s confidence and get them excited and ready for the new year.

Step 4: Discover New Directions and Opportunities

Beyond establishing successes and learnings, an effective year-end review can help highlight new directions and opportunities. The opportunities might lie in untapped markets, changing customer trends, or evolving marketing strategies. This feeds into building more creative and effective marketing campaigns that can drive more revenue.

For example, at Tote + Pears, we found our clients were struggling to execute some of our strategies because they didn’t understand their core audience as well as we did. To fix that, we brought in more educational components to our offerings.

Step 5: Reap the Benefits

Armed with the insights from our latest review, our team at Tote + Pears is able to anticipate audience behavior and preferences, better place our marketing strategies, and effectively prepare for the new year. As a result of our latest review, we're already embarking on new marketing messaging for 2024 to ensure clients are well aware of our capabilities and how we can continue to serve them in this changing world.

Conducting a year-end review helps us connect more deeply with our customers, enhancing their journey with our brand, and not just our revenue figures.

Year-end marketing reviews aren’t just a box-ticking exercise; instead, they can be a powerful tool to help you learn and grow your business. You can either conduct them internally or bring in an agency or a marketing consultant to do it for you. The insights you gather may be just what you need for business growth.