If you’re looking to build a successful business, it's important to try to do all you can to ensure your staff stays happy and motivated. In many cases, finding and retaining productive employees can come down to money. According to job search website Joblist’s 2023 U.S. Jobs Market Report, a survey of 30,074 Joblist users, better pay and benefits was cited as the number-one reason employees said they planned to quit their jobs in 2023. Unfortunately, small and midsize businesses (SMBs) often don’t have the financial resources to compete with larger businesses when it comes to salaries. As a result, they need to find creative ways to compensate their best employees.
One way to make it easier for SMBs to attract and keep their most talented workers is to consider profit-sharing plans. As the name implies, these plans allow companies to distribute profits to employees over time using an organized plan. Sharing profits with employees can create a stronger workplace culture, with everyone working toward the shared goal of company success.
Read on to find out how profit-sharing plans work, and how they can help you attract new talent, increase productivity, and build better staff retention.
How Do Profit-Sharing Plans Work?
A profit-sharing plan is a type of employee compensation. Companies calculate their profits over a period, such as a financial year, and give a percentage of that money to employees. Profits can be distributed various ways: they might be given directly to employees each quarter or year, in a lump sum at retirement, or even provided as shares in the company. Some companies may have eligibility criteria for participation, such as minimum tenure or performance metrics.
Profit sharing can be a win-win for both employees and companies. For employees, it can provide an additional source of income based on company success, while creating a direct connection between employee efforts and financial rewards. For employers, these plans can not only help attract and retain top talent in competitive markets, but also foster a sense of ownership and commitment among staff, leading to enhanced productivity and morale.
What Are the Main Types of Profit-Sharing Plans?
In the U.S., there are three types of profit-sharing plans, each with its own set of rules, benefits, and considerations.
Traditional
In this scenario, everyone receives a share of profits based on an equal percentage of their salary. For example, if a rate is set at 1%, someone earning $50,000 annually would receive a profit-share payment of $500 per year, while someone earning $200,000 would receive $2,000. This method helps ensure all employees receive an equitable distribution.
New Comparability
This type of profit-share plan allows companies to allocate different rates of profits to different groups of employees based on specific criteria defined by the company, such as job function or seniority. For example, full-time workers might receive a higher profit share percentage than part-time workers. Although this method gives companies flexibility to reward certain employee groups, it’s important to vet new comparability plans with experts to help prevent inadvertent discrimination against some groups. For example, the company's profit sharing should benefit a broad cross-section of employees and not just the highest earners.
Age-Weighted
In this model, both age and salary are considered when calculating profit-share allocations. For example, an age-weighted profit-sharing plan allocates a higher percentage of shared contributions to older employees, based on the logic that they have less time to save. As with new comparability plans, age-weighted plans should be evaluated by experts to avoid the risk of age discrimination.
Beyond these three calculation methods, profit-sharing plans can also differ in their payout form – either cash or stock. Cash-based distributions can be delivered as cash bonuses or checks at regular intervals, typically annually. Companies can also deposit cash into deferred accounts that employees then access after retirement. These deferred accounts can often be invested, offering additional income growth opportunities. Companies can also distribute profits as company stock, which employees can choose to keep or sell.
Choosing the Right Profit-Sharing Plan for Your Employees
When choosing a profit-share model, think about what will most benefit your employees. To get a sense of their needs, consider sitting down with some employees and carefully explaining the available profit-sharing options, including payment schedules. Then try to solicit feedback on everything from their understanding of each type of plan to their perceived value of each option, which would most motivate them, what preferences they may have, as well as any concerns. Surveys can be another way to gauge employee response and to figure out what resonates.
You may also want to consider seeking guidance from financial or human resource experts familiar with profit-sharing models. Their expertise can help you navigate any complexities while making sure the chosen plan is compliant with legal and financial standards.
Determining which plan makes the most sense for your company can depend on many factors, such as employee demographics, profitability history, administrative capacity, and budgets.
What Are the Benefits of Profit Sharing?
Implementing a company-wide profit-sharing plan, especially at a small business, can yield several important benefits.
- Motivation: Profit-sharing plans inherently link employee rewards to company performance, potentially boosting employee motivation and productivity.
- ·Retention and recruitment: Profit sharing can make a small business more attractive to potential employees. It can also help retain existing talent by creating a stronger tie between the employee’s financial success and that of the company.
- Financial flexibility: Unlike fixed bonuses, profit sharing is tied to a company's profitability. In challenging years, profit-sharing payouts can be reduced, helping the business maintain financial stability.
- Morale: When all employees benefit from company success, it can build camaraderie and a collective drive toward common goals.
- Improved culture: With a stake in profits, employees may think more like stakeholders, leading them to make decisions that benefit the long-term health of the company.
Are There Any Downsides to Profit Sharing?
While profit-sharing plans have many advantages, they’re not without their challenges.
- Administrative burden: Implementing and maintaining profit-sharing plans can require a significant amount of oversight, including rigorous regulatory compliance and meticulous record-keeping.
- ·Unpredictability: Because profit sharing is directly tied to a company's profitability, contributions might be reduced or eliminated in challenging years, which can adversely affect employee morale.
- Delayed gratification: Deferred plans in particular can be less immediately gratifying. Employees might have to wait years to see tangible benefits, potentially dampening the incentive’s appeal. In addition, if employees leave before they're fully vested in a deferred plan, they might lose out on some of their accrued funds.
- Perception of inequity: New comparability plans can inadvertently create disparities in distribution amounts, which may lead to perceptions of favoritism and morale issues. In addition, age-weighted plans can be less beneficial for younger employees, which can affect recruitment and retention.
- Cost: Despite its many benefits, profit sharing is an added cost that companies could utilize for growth or other opportunities.
The Bottom Line
Profit-sharing plans can be a highly effective way for SMBs to attract and retain top talent. Determining which plan makes the most sense for your company can depend on many factors, such as employee demographics, profitability history, administrative capacity, and budgets. It’s wise for SMBs to consider consulting experts in the field to gauge options and implications.
Photo: Getty Images
